Wake Up Dead Man (2025)

Poster for “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

If critical and commercial success guarantees one thing in Hollywood, it’s a sequel. Glass Onion, the second film in the Knives Out franchise, was undoubtedly that. The film did respectable business at the box office for the one week it was in theaters and logged over 209.5 million hours worth of views in its first ten days on Netflix. Additionally, the film was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay. These factors would almost always guarantee a sequel, except that a sequel was guaranteed long before the film’s release. Remember, after the success of the first Knives Out, Netflix paid a “mind-boggling” $469 million for the rights to make two sequels. With Wake Up Dead Man, writer/director/producer Rian Johnson completes his contract and delivers a much darker, but just as elaborate, installment. Before going any further, I do want to issue a spoiler alert.

Rian Johnson and Daniel Craig.

I’ll start by saying that I’ve had plenty of time to re-watch both Knives Out and Glass Onion, but Wake Up Dead Man is relatively new. I’ve watched the film twice now, once in theaters and once on Netflix. I’m sure I’ll discover new things the more I watch it. Getting into the post, I do know that Rian Johnson started writing the third film in early 2023, but had to stop due to the 2023 Writers’ Guild of America strike. Once the strike officially ended, Johnson finished the script by the end of the year. The first set of casting was announced in May 2024, marking Jeremy Renner’s first film after his near-fatal snowplow accident on New Year’s Day 2023. Filming began on June 10 and wrapped on August 17. According to Glenn Close, her role was reduced because she fell ill with both COVID and RSV during filming.

Rian Johnson directing “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

The movie follows the unexplained death of the controversial Monsignor Wicks (Josh Brolin) in a small New York parish and the young priest, Jud Duplenticy (Josh O’Connor), who is accused of committing the crime. Local police chief Geraldine Scott (Mila Kunis) enlists the help of Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) to help solve this “unsolvable” crime. Rather brilliantly, Johnson changes up the formula. The main character in this film is Jud. This is his journey. In fact, aside from a brief appearance at the start of the film, Blanc doesn’t appear until 40 minutes into the movie. When Blanc does show up, the chemistry and rapport between the two men is dynamic, resembling the relationship between Blanc and Marta in the first film and Blanc and Helen in the second.

Daniel Craig in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Josh O’Connor in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Mila Kunis in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

Jud, after punching a disliked priest, is sent as punishment to help revitalize Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude, run by the divisive Monsignor Wicks. The flock of parishioners is shrinking and “calcifying”, according to Bistrop Langstrom (a Jeffrey Wright cameo). The flock is eccentric, to put it mildly, and they all seem to be under the spell of Wicks. Church regulars include Martha (Glenn Close), the devoted church secretary and right hand woman to Wicks, Samson (Thomas Haden Church), the church’s groundskeeper and Martha’s not so secret admirer, Nat Sharp (Jeremy Renner), a local doctor who has succumbed to alcoholism after his wife leaves him, Lee Ross (Andrew Scott) a former best selling author who is now a conspiracy theorist, and Simone (Cailee Spaeny), a former cellist crippled by pain and hoping for a miracle. Then, there are the Dravens – Vera and Cy. Vera is a tightly wound lawyer who took over her father’s law firm. Her father was Wicks’ old drinking buddy and one day brought home a young boy, Cy, whom Vera raised as a son, despite everyone knowing they were brother and sister. Cy, now an adult, is a conservative online influencer and aspiring politician who likes to further the divide amongst people.

Kerry Washington and Glenn Close in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Josh Brolin in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Jeremy Renner in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

Johnson set out to make each film in the series different, and he succeeded in spades. Knives Out was a fresh and fun countryside thriller. Glass Onion was a funny, tropical whodunnit. Wake Up Dead Man is a dark, at times humorous, mystery of faith. If Johnson switched the release order of the sequels, neither would have been as successful as they were. Glass Onion was an escape to a warm environment during a pandemic. Wake Up Dead Man is a cold and somber reflection on life post-pandemic. Dead Man also feels more relevant to the time of its release. When Knives Out was released, we were in a presidential administration that fostered distrust of the media and fueled family discord. The first film, without naming anyone specifically, touches on the subject. When Glass Onion was released, we were in a different presidential administration. The distrust and discourse were still there, best illustrated by the character of Duke Cody, but things seemed a little brighter. Now, in 2025, the guy who was president in 2019 when the first film was released is back in office, and the distrust and discourse are back with a vengeance. The sad truth is that we live in a fractured world, and this film is a perfect representation of the time we live in. I don’t like to get political, so we’ll just leave it at that, although it doesn’t take someone like Benoit Blanc to read between the lines. Oh, and speaking of Blanc, the contrast in his appearance between the two films is stark. In Glass Onion, he’s got short hair, clean-shaven, and sun-kissed skin. In Wake Up Dead Man, he’s got noticeably longer hair and a short, stubbly gray beard. He looks like he’s aged more than the three years between entries.

Andrew Scott in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Thomas Haden Church in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Cailee Spaeny in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

The central theme of the film is love versus hate, exemplified by Father Jud and Monsignor Wicks. From a visual standpoint, Jud and Wicks couldn’t be more different. Jud is young and slender, looking much younger than Josh O’Connor’s 35 years. Wicks is a good amount heavier, with long gray hair to his shoulders and a long gray beard, looking much older than Brolin’s 57 years. Their outlooks on life and the church set them apart. Wicks runs his church on a mixture of anger, fear, and shame. His “passionate” sermons are rooted in anger. He radicalizes his flock of regulars, which only adds fuel to the fire when Cy posts his rants online. He thinks his church is under attack, not only by the mainstream media, but by Father Jud. The first thing he asks Father Jud when they meet is, “Are you taking my church away from me?” Jud tells him no, and Wicks asks him to take his confession. During the confession, Wicks confesses to masturbating several times and clearly makes Jud uncomfortable as he explains his methods for getting the job done. Wicks confesses the same sin to Jud over the span of several months until Jud confronts him and tells him that because Martha keeps medical files in the church office, he knows that Wicks had a surgery that prevents him from getting an erection. These were just mind tricks that Wicks liked to play on Jud to remind him who was in control.

Daryl McCormack in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.
Daniel Craig in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

Jud, on the other hand, runs on kindness and love. In his past life, Jud was a boxer who, at age 17, killed a man in the ring. He had hate in his heart, but found Jesus. He tells Langstrom that he became a priest to show broken people like himself the power of God’s love. Jud tries to reach the church’s parishioners but struggles because of their indoctrination by Wicks. When Jud holds a prayer group without Wicks, the flock is outraged, as is Wicks. They abruptly leave, telling Jud that his coup failed. Despite this setback, he is insistent that he will get through to them. After confronting Wicks about his inability to get an erection, the priests switch roles, with Wicks taking Jud’s confession. Under the guise of confession, Jud tells Wicks all his concerns with the flock. He goes on and essentially attacks Wicks’ character and his treatment of the flock. They all need help, but he brings up Simone in particular. Jud knows she’s been donating a lot of money to the church because she believes Wicks can perform a miracle to cure her of her pain, as long as she is a good steward. Jud sees that as Wicks leading him on. After one too many examples, Wick punches Jud in the stomach. He taunts him, “What are you going to do? Are you going to lie there and take it?” Jud jumps up into a fighting stance and puts his dukes up. “Good, you’re angry, and you’re ready to fight,” Wicks tells him. That’s what this church needs. Wicks truly believes the church is under attack from the outside world. This prompts Jud to go toe to toe with Wicks and tell him, “You are a cancer to the people and the church, and I will do anything to cut you out.” With that, it’s a war between love and hate.

Josh O’Connor and Josh Brolin in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

The film also does a good job of portraying these men of the cloth as mortal men. As a former boxer, Jud’s anger gets him in trouble. He’s sent to our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude (an apt name under Wicks) because he punched a priest, who by Langstrom’s account, “was a bit of a dick anyway.” Jud, at least, knows when he is succumbing to these human flaws. He admits after Wick’s death that he was upset, not because Wick was dead, but because Wick won. Wicks, on the other hand, either does not care or is oblivious to his flaws. He has two major flaws that come to mind.

Daniel Craig in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

The first one is greed. Wicks’ grandfather, Prentice, was the first priest of the church. He was a widower with a daughter when he took his vows. He also had a serious fortune that caused a lot of trouble in his life. Before Prentice died, he put all his money into a diamond he referred to as “Eve’s Apple,” the cause of all evil. However, upon his death, Eve’s Apple could not be found. Some say he donated it to people experiencing poverty. Others say he destroyed it. It’s been missing for nearly sixty years, but rumors of its location surface, and he will do anything to obtain it. With that fortune, he could retire and leave the church and the pathetic flock behind.

The other big flaw Wicks has is his judgmentalism. Not a week goes by, as Jud points out, that he doesn’t scare off a newcomer to the church with his intense and judgmental homilies. I mentioned Eve’s Apple and the cost of Prentice’s fortune. I didn’t say that Prentice’s daughter, Grace, was a single woman who became pregnant by a “transient,” producing Wicks. Prentice told Grace that if she lived with him and lived a good life, she would inherit all of his wealth. When Prentice died, and the money was nowhere to be found, she destroyed the church in anger. The “harlot whore,” as the parish referred to her. They even leave the outline of the crucifix bare as a reminder of the “harlot whore.” Wicks is generally judgmental, but he was angry with his mother for raising him without a father, something he considered a disadvantage. You know that you’re judgmental when you refer to your own mother as a “harlot whore.” Despite being a man of the cloth, Wicks is a nasty man underneath it all.

The flock of parishioners in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

Aside from Jud and Blanc, the most fleshed-out character is Martha. As Wicks’ right-hand woman, she’s known him all of his life. She was a little girl when Prentice founded the church, and he took great care of her. Prentice treated her like the daughter Grace never was. Martha saw Prentice take his last breath and collapse at the altar. Even as a young child, she shames Grace and calls her the “harlot whore.” She, of course, grows up and practically lives at the church. She acts as secretary, filing the paperwork, organizing the book club (Oprah’s book club), laundering the vestments, and everything in between. If there’s a body within the church, Martha knows where it is buried. Her devotion to both the church and Wicks is played for laughs. Her first appearance seemingly comes out of nowhere in the scene where Jud first meets Wicks. She pops out behind Jud and tells Wicks that she polished the silver because it was “looking blotchy.”

Additionally, when Father Jud holds his prayer meeting, she is the first to text Wicks, effectively making her his spy within the parish. As the film progresses, however, we learn that her devotion is not to Wicks but to Prentice and his vision for the church. For sixty years, she kept the secret of Eve’s Apple, but let it slip in a confession to Wicks. Realizing her mistake, it seems she will do anything to stop Wicks or anybody from unearthing it. It’s also worth mentioning her relationship with Samson. Samson openly admires her and tells her, “I’ll do anything for you, my love.” She simply laughs him off. It’s only when tragedy strikes that she realizes just how much she cared for him. Watching it made me wonder, did Martha have good intentions and just go about it the wrong way, or is she just as corrupt as the rest of the flock?

Glenn Close and Josh O’Connor in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

I said it already, but I will repeat it. This film is dark. Easily the darkest in the series. The film tackles faith, mystery, love, hatred, deception, religion, heresy, and, of course, murder. (Spoiler alert) Dead bodies are even placed into vats of acid. That’s some Breaking Bad shit. That being said, there are some funny moments and easter eggs. Noah Segan, who played Trooper Wagner in the first film and Derol in the second, is back as the owner of the hell bar Dr. Nat likes to frequent. Though the movie stands on its own, there is a subtle reference to the first film when Geraldine tells Blanc that she will have to get Detective Elliott a fruit basket for referring him to her. Detective Elliott, played by LaKeith Stanfield, investigated Harlan Thrombey’s death in Knives Out. Similarly to how Richard quoted Hamilton in Knives Out and Leslie Odom Jr. appeared in Glass Onion, Jeremy Renner’s “Rennin’ Hot” small-batch hot sauce plays a vital role in one scene in Glass Onion. Renner, of course, plays Nat Sharp. Of course, no comedy would be complete without some good old-fashioned dick jokes. In a scene used in the trailer, Prentice’s white crypt has been vandalized with graffiti dicks. Jud talks to Samson as he paints over the graffiti when Martha walks by and quips, “It makes me sick. Painting rocketships on his final resting place.” The two men share a look that says, “I’m not going to tell her.”

Cailee Spaeny, Kerry Washington, Thomas Haden Church, Glenn Close, and Daryl McCormack in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

I’ll be honest with you. This is my least favorite installment in the franchise. Now, that’s not me saying it’s bad by any means, but it pales in comparison to its predecessors. There are two main reasons. First, it’s just too dark. The first ones were light and fun. While the mystery remains, the fun feels diminished. The second, and perhaps most important, are the characters. Each film features Blanc, a sidekick (Marta, Helen, or Jud), and a supporting cast of characters. In the first film, the Thrombey family is just a bunch of rich, entitled assholes. It’s fun to watch them banter, and you don’t feel bad when they lose the house to Marta. In Glass Onion, the main characters are all selfish and shady. They will do anything to hold onto Miles, including committing perjury, but will also turn on each other to protect their own interests.

Josh O’Connor and Daniel Craig in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

The key here is that they are all well-defined, and it’s fun to see them banter, even if they are more morally compromised than the Thrombeys. In this film, we have ten supporting characters – more than Glass Onion but less than Knives Out. While the Thrombeys and the disruptors of Glass Onion were not great people, they each had some redeeming qualities (mostly). Except for Jud and maybe Martha, these people are not likable. I see no redeeming qualities in any of them. The characters are pretty well-defined and serve their purpose, but I don’t think any of them are memorable. What I remember less than a week after re-watching the film are the characters of Jud, Martha, and Wicks, who was the asshole who gets murdered, and Cy, because he’s a toxic little shit. Jeremy Renner, Andrew Scott, Kerry Washington, and Thomas Haden Church are all great actors, but they are wasted here. I also don’t think Mila Kunis brings anything to the role of the police chief either. It just didn’t feel as lively as the others, I suppose.

Mila Kunis, Andrew Scott, Daryl McCormack, Glenn Close, Cailee Spaeny, and Kerry Washington in “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

Making these movies has to be hard, but Johnson is 3-for-3. He set out to write three different murder mysteries anchored by a single character, and he succeeded. Each installment is distinct enough to stand on its own merit. While I did say that this was my least favorite in the franchise and go off on the characters, there are some redeeming qualities. The film is definitely more thematic than its predecessors. It made me think a lot more. I also have to give Johnson credit because the mystery was just as tightly constructed as the rest. Although my dad passed away before this film was released, he loved the others. He tended to solve the mystery halfway through a movie if I put one on. It was annoying. However, he couldn’t do that with the other films, and I’d like to think he wouldn’t have been able to with this one either. On Oscar morning, part of me was hoping for a nomination in the Adapted Screenplay category since the first one got in for Original and the sequel for Adapted. It would have been cool, I imagine, for Johnson to also be three for three in Oscar nominations. Alas, it was not meant to be.

Daniel Craig, Josh O’Connor, and Rian Johnson behind the scenes of “Wake Up Dead Man.” Netflix.

While Wake Up Dead Man satisfied the Netflix contract, it might not be the end of the franchise. No deal has been signed, but Johnson said he would love to keep making films as long as Daniel Craig is in and the audience wants them. That’s fine with me. I would love to see more, but I would also like to see Johnson work on other projects. I’m not a science fiction fan, but I adored his film, Looper. With a new era dawning at Lucasfilm, maybe he’ll return to a galaxy far, far away? Who knows. If Johnson’s next film is something new, I’ll be excited. If it’s another Knives Out, I will also be excited and curious to see how he tops himself. That’s it for my series on Knives Out. I would like to thank you for staying with me as I unraveled the mystery.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *